Leading in the Security Industry

April 12, 2023

The United States and China have a significant economic relationship, but not without many areas of tension and competition, including trade, military power, technology, and human rights.

China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is a massive infrastructure and development project that aims to connect China to the rest of the world. The BRI includes a vast network of roads, railways, ports, and other infrastructure projects across Asia, Europe, Africa, and the Middle East. While the initiative is touted to boost economic growth and development in participating countries, it has also been criticized and concerned over its potential impact on global politics, economics, and security.

Economic competition is a critical threat that China poses to the United States. China is the world’s second-largest economy and has made significant strides in recent years to become a global leader in technology and innovation. This has led to concerns that China is threatening the United States’ economic dominance and could overtake it as the world’s leading economic power shortly.

Trade is one of the main areas of economic competition between China and the United States. The two countries have engaged in a trade war in recent years, each imposing tariffs on the other’s goods. In addition, the United States has accused China of unfair trade practices, such as stealing intellectual property and manipulating currency. At the same time, China has criticized the United States for protectionist policies that limit its access to U.S. markets. Technology also exists as economic competition between the two countries. China has invested significantly in emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence, 5G networks, and quantum computing. This has raised concerns in the United States that China is developing technologies that could be used to undermine U.S. military and economic power and infringe on the privacy and security of U.S. citizens.

In addition to economic competition, China poses a military threat to the United States. China has recently been modernizing and expanding its military, focusing on developing capabilities that could challenge U.S. military power in the Asia-Pacific region. This includes investing in new weapons systems such as aircraft carriers, ballistic missiles, and cyber capabilities. China’s military expansion has led to concerns that it is seeking to challenge U.S. dominance in the region and could potentially engage in military conflict with the United States. The United States has responded by increasing its military presence in the region and strengthening alliances with countries such as Japan and South Korea.

China threatens the United States in the realm of human rights. For example, China has been criticized for their treatment of Uighur Muslims in the Xinjiang region, where the Chinese government has detained over a million Uighurs in internment camps. China has also been criticized for its crackdown on pro-democracy protesters in Hong Kong and its treatment of Tibetans. The United States has responded to these human rights abuses by imposing sanctions on Chinese officials and companies involved in the detention of Uighurs and the crackdown on Hong Kong protesters. The United States has also criticized China’s treatment of Tibetans and called for greater religious freedom.

The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) was first announced in 2013 by Chinese President Xi Jinping to enhance connectivity and economic cooperation across the Eurasian continent. The project includes two main components: the “Silk Road Economic Belt” and the “21st Century Maritime Silk Road”. The former refers to the land-based transportation infrastructure connecting China to Central Asia, Russia, and Europe. In contrast, the latter refers to the maritime routes linking China to Southeast Asia, South Asia, the Middle East, and Africa.  The BRI has been praised for its potential to promote economic growth and development in participating countries. China has pledged over $1 trillion to fund infrastructure projects under the initiative, which has the potential to stimulate economic growth and job creation in developing countries. The initiative also aims to improve connectivity and trade between China and other countries, which could lead to increased market access and opportunities for businesses.

However, the BRI has also been criticized by some countries and analysts. China has been accused of using the initiative to expand its global influence and gain access to strategic resources and markets. There is the potential for the initiative to increase China’s political and economic influence in participating countries.  In addition, critics argue that China’s involvement in infrastructure projects could lead to dependence on Chinese investment and influence, potentially creating a debt trap for participating countries. There is concern that the initiative could potentially exacerbate regional conflicts and tensions. Some analysts argue that the BRI could contribute to geo-political tensions and instability in regions with conflicts, such as South Asia and the Middle East. For example, China’s involvement in the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor, a major infrastructure project under the BRI, has been criticized by India due to its disputed border with Pakistan.

The BRI has been judged for its need for more transparency and accountability. Critics argue that the initiative needs more transparency in the financing, environmental and social impact assessments, and contract bidding processes. In addition, heightened concerns have been raised about the potential for corruption and lack of oversight in implementing infrastructure projects under the initiative.  The BRI has also been met with environmental apprehension, as many of the infrastructure projects under the initiative are in environmentally sensitive areas. For example, the BRI includes plans for over 700 coal-fired power plants in participating countries, which could have significant environmental and health impacts.

The BRI has created questions about cybersecurity and information security. China’s involvement in critical infrastructure projects in other countries raises uneasiness about the potential for espionage and cyber-attacks and the potential for China to control information flows through the infrastructure.  In response to the above concerns surrounding the BRI, some countries have been cautious about participating. For example, India has not officially joined the initiative with the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor in mind. Other countries, such as Malaysia and Pakistan, have scaled back their participation in the initiative due to debt and transparency.

China poses a significant threat to the United States in several areas, including economic competition, military power, technology, and human rights. The Belt and Road Initiative has the potential to be a significant driver of economic growth and development in participating countries. However, it poses significant risks and challenges, including concerns about China’s political and economic influence, regional tensions, lack of transparency and accountability, environmental impact, and cybersecurity. As the initiative continues to expand, it is essential. The relationship between the two countries is complex and fraught with tension, and it will likely remain so in the coming years. Therefore, it will be necessary for the United States to manage this relationship carefully and to work with its allies to address the challenges posed by China’s rise as a global power.

For more articles like this one visit our blog section.